Independent Insurance Agency
New Springfield, OH & Zelienople, PA

We simplify insurance so you can live stress-free.

MVP Insurance is 100% independent. We shop and compare policies from multiple carriers to find you the right coverage at the right rate for your home, your car, and your business.

Pennsylvania: (724) 453-1122

5.0

Google Rating

280

Five-Star Google Reviews

2

Local Offices

100%

Independent

Your Local Independent Insurance Agency

Hundreds of local families and businesses trust MVP Insurance

David Varrati and Joshua Medure have been friends since childhood. They started MVP Insurance in Northeast Ohio to give people a better insurance experience: honest advice, real options, and a team that picks up the phone.

Today we serve clients from two offices, New Springfield, Ohio and Zelienople, Pennsylvania, where we carry on the service Griffin Insurance clients have known for years. As an independent agency, we work for you, not for an insurance company.

Learn More About Us

We Can Cover Everything That's Important To You

When it comes to shopping for insurance, there are hundreds, if not thousands of options. We proactively shop & compare your policies to find the best coverage & rate.

  • Homeowners & Auto Insurance
  • Business Owners Insurance
  • Term Life Insurance
  • Cyber Liability Insurance
  • General Liability Insurance

Why Clients Choose MVP

The MVP difference

Insurance should be simple. Here is how we keep it that way.

We're Local

Two offices in Ohio and Pennsylvania. You talk to people who know your town and remember your name.

100% Independent

We work for our clients, not an insurance carrier, so we shop multiple companies for every policy.

Technology Driven

Online quotes and a quick policy import through Canopy. We use tools that make your life easier.

We Shop Your Policies Every Year

Two offices in Ohio and Pennsylvania. You talk to people who know your town and remember your name.

Quick, Accurate Pricing

Share a few details and we return clear options with the coverage explained in plain language.

24/7 Claims Reporting

Report a claim through your carrier at any time. Our team can help with questions during office hours.

Your Local Licensed Insurance Team

The people behind your policy

Familiar faces. Honest advice. A team you can talk to.

Owner

David Varrati

I'm a Slippery Rock University graduate. I coach youth sports and have spent 10+ years protecting Ohio families.

Owner

Joshua Medure

I'm a Penn State marketing graduate. I coach youth football and lead our insurance strategy with 10+ years in the business.

“We have been buddies from an early age. We decided that we wanted to start our own business in Northeast Ohio.”

David Varrati & Joshua Medure

Marcie Presto

Office Manager

Ohio

Michelle Plaufcan

Personal Lines Account Manager

Pennsylvania

Marcie Wirtjes

Personal Lines Account Manager

Terry Dobson

Commercial Sales Agent

Edi Reinhart

Commercial Account Manager

Bethany McFall

Account Manager

5-Star Rated on Google

What our clients say

Our clients say it best. Here is what they share about working with Josh, Dave, and the MVP team.

Insurance made simple,
from people who live here too.

Personal Insurance in Ohio & Pennsylvania

Coverage for your home, your car, and your family

Protect the everyday things that mean the most to you.

Homeowners Insurance

Your home is one of your most valuable assets. We compare carriers to protect the house, your belongings, and your liability.

Car Insurance

We proactively shop the market to find the best combination of coverage and price for every car in your driveway.

Renters Insurance

Own a condo or rent your home? We insure your unit, your belongings, and your personal liability at a fair rate.

Umbrella Insurance

Extra liability protection above your home and auto policies. Large coverage limits for a small added cost each year.

Life Insurance

Protect the people who rely on you most, so they can keep their home and lifestyle if the unexpected happens.

Flood Insurance

Standard home policies do not cover flooding. We help you add flood coverage through the NFIP or a private carrier before the water rises.

Business Insurance in Ohio & Pennsylvania

No matter how big or small your business, we protect it

Practical coverage for your people, your property, and the work you do.

General Liability

Protection when someone outside your business is hurt or their property is damaged because of your work or your premises.
Explore More

Business Owners Policy

One policy that bundles property and liability for small businesses. Simple, affordable protection for your building and contents.
Explore More

Professional Liability

Protection when a client says your advice or work caused them a loss. A staple of any solid commercial package.
Explore More

Commercial Property

Helping landlords and commercial real estate investors insure their buildings, habitational risks, and the rental income they produce.
Explore More

Workers Compensation

Protecting your employees is protecting your business. Medical bills and lost wages covered when someone gets hurt on the job.
Explore More

Commercial Auto

With a wide selection of commercial auto carriers, we find the right coverage for your trucks, vans, and drivers.
Explore More

Industries We Serve

Insurance built around the work you do

Every industry carries different risks. We know the coverage each one needs and shop the carriers that write it well.

Contractors Insurance

General contractors, remodelers, roofers, and trade crews. We cover the liability, tools, vehicles, and workers your jobs depend on.

Plumber Insurance

Water damage claims follow plumbers everywhere. We cover your liability, your tools, your van, and your crew, job after job.

Restaurant Insurance

Kitchens, bars, and cafes face fire, spoilage, and slip risks. We package property, liability, and liquor coverage in one plan.

Our Process

Our process is simple.
We take care of our clients.

01

Tell Us What You Need

Fill out a quick quote request, or import your current policy through Canopy in a few clicks so we see exactly what you have.

02

Tell Us What You Need

We compare coverage and rates from the carriers we represent, then explain your options in plain language.



03

Get Covered & Stay Covered

Your policy starts and we stay with you. We review it every year and help you through every claim.



Serving Ohio & Pennsylvania

Two local offices,
one friendly team

Two offices, one team: stop by, call, or start online and we handle the rest.

Ohio Office

New Springfield

13823 Grant St, New Springfield, OH 44443

Pennsylvania Office

Zelienople

Formerly Griffin Insurance

108 E Grandview Ave, Zelienople, PA 16063

Insurance Questions, Answered

Questions our clients ask

A little clarity can make your next step easier.

  • What does an independent insurance agency do?

    An independent agency works with multiple insurance companies. We compare your options, explain the differences, and help you choose coverage that fits your needs.

  • Can MVP Insurance quote both my home and auto?

    Yes. We can compare home and auto insurance options together. We explain available discounts and check how the policies work together.

  • Do you insure businesses in Ohio and Pennsylvania?

    Yes. We help businesses in both states compare options for property, liability, employees, and commercial vehicles. The right policy depends on your work and the risks involved.

  • How do I import my current policy for a quote?

    Use our Canopy policy import link to share your current policy information. Our team can then review your existing coverage and compare options with you.

  • How do I report a claim or make a payment?

    Visit our Client Center for billing and claims information. You can also call either office for help finding the right carrier contact.

  • How often should I review my insurance?

    Review your coverage each year and after a major change, such as a move, new vehicle, or business expansion. Tell us what changed so we can help you check your protection.

Contractors & Tradesmen

General contractors, roofers, electricians and plumbers. We cover liability, tools, vehicles and crews so every job stays protected.

Explore More

Insurance Tips & News

Insurance tips for Ohio and Pennsylvania families and businesses

Practical ideas for protecting what matters to you.

How to File an Insurance Complaint in Pennsylvania: What the Insurance Department Handles, How to

How to File an Insurance Complaint in Pennsylvania: A Step-by-Step Guide

24 October 2026
How to File an Insurance Complaint in Pennsylvania. What Pennsylvania households should know, explained in plain English by a local independent agent.
Pennsylvania Insurance Guaranty Association Explained: What Happens When an Insurer Fails, Claim

Pennsylvania Insurance Guaranty Association Explained: What Happens When an Insurer Fails

24 October 2026
Pennsylvania Insurance Guaranty Association Explained. What Pennsylvania homeowners should know, explained in plain English by a local independent agent.
Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Cancellation and Nonrenewal Rules: Notice Periods, Allowed Reasons Under

Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Cancellation and Nonrenewal Rules: What Drivers Should Know

24 October 2026
Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Cancellation and Nonrenewal Rules. What Pennsylvania drivers should know, in plain English.

Covington office, Monday through Friday

Call

614 E. Boston St., Covington, LA 70433

58418 Tyler Drive, Slidell, LA 70461

Request Your Free Quote

Let's make insurance simple for you

Tell us what you need. We will help you explore your options.

Contact Us

Call Ohio

Call Pennsylvania